| TABLE
4. Comparison of Intrapartum/Postpartum Regimens for HIV-Infected
Women in Labor Who Have Had No Prior Antiretroviral Therapy
(Scenario 3) |
| Drug
Regimen |
Source
of Evidence |
Maternal
Intrapartum |
Infant
Postpartum |
Data
on Transmission |
Advantages |
Disadvantages |
| Nevirapine |
Clinical
trial, Africa; compared to oral ZDV given intrapartum and for
1 week to the infant |
Single
200 mg oral dose at onset of labor |
Single
2 mg/kg oral dose at age 48-72 hours*
*If
the mother received nevirapine less than 1 hour prior to delivery,
the infant was given 2 mg/kg oral nevirapine as soon as possible
after birth and again at 48-72 hours.
|
Transmission
at 6 weeks 12% with nevirapine compared to 21% with ZDV, a 47%
(95% CI, 20-64%) reduction |
Inexpensive
Oral
regimen
Simple,
easy to administer
Can
give directly observed treatment
|
Unknown
efficacy if mother has nevirapine-resistant virus |
| ZDV/3TC |
Clinical
trial, Africa; compared to placebo |
ZDV
600 mg orally at onset of labor, followed by 300 mg orally every
3 hours until delivery
AND
3TC150
mg orally at onset of labor, followed by 150 mg orally every
12 hours until delivery
|
ZDV
4 mg/kg orally every 12 hours
AND
3TC
2 mg/kg orally every 12 hours for 7 days
|
Transmission
at 6 weeks 10% with ZDV/3TC compared to 17% with placebo, a
38% reduction |
Oral
regimen
Compliance
easier than 6 weeks of ZDV alone as infant regimen is only
1 week
|
Potential
toxicity of multiple drug exposure |
| ZDV |
Epidemiologic
data, U.S.; compared to no ZDV treatment |
2
mg/kg intravenous bolus, followed by continuous infusion of
1 mg/kg/hr until delivery |
2
mg/kg orally every 6 hours for 6 weeks |
Transmission
10% with ZDV compared to 27% with no ZDV treatment, a 62% (95%
CI, 19-82%) reduction |
Has
been standard recommendation before clinical trial results |
Requires
intravenous administration and availability of ZDV intravenous
formulation
Compliance
with 6 week infant regimen
|
| ZDV
and Nevirapine |
Theoretical |
ZDV
2 mg/kg intravenous bolus, followed by continuous infusion of
1 mg/kg/hr until delivery
AND
Nevirapine
single 200 mg oral dose at onset of labor
|
ZDV
2 mg/kg orally every 6 hours for 6 weeks
AND
Nevirapine
single 2 mg/kg oral dose at age 48-72 hours
|
No
data |
Potential
benefit if maternal virus is resistant to either nevirapine
or ZDV
Synergistic
inhibition of HIV replication with combination in vitro
|
Requires
intravenous administration and availability of ZDV intravenous
formulation
Compliance
with 6 week infant ZDV regimen
Unknown
efficacy and limited toxicity data
|