
|
Clinical
Progression, Survival, and Immune Recovery During Antiretroviral
Therapy in Patients with HIV-1 and Hepatitis C Virus Coinfection:
The Swiss HIV Cohort Study [Greub G, et al. Lancet 2000;
356;1800]:
This is a report from the Swiss HIV Cohort Study to determine the
effect of HCV on HIV infection. The Swiss Cohort includes 3,111
patients given HAART, including 1,015 with positive HCV serology.
Among those with HCV, 88% had a history of injection drug use; of
the 1,954 who were HCV seronegative, only 5% had injection drug
use as a risk factor for HIV. The median follow-up period was 28
months. Death was ascribed to end-stage liver disease in 6 of the
1,157 with HCV-positive serology (0.5%). Patients with positive
HCV serology had higher rates of AIDS-defining opportunistic infections
(7.5% versus 4.7%; p = 0.001) and a smaller number with a CD4 cell
count increase of at least 50/mm3
(75% versus 84%; OR = 0.8). The authors conclude that HCV
coinfection appears to increase morbidity and mortality and that
the impaired CD4 cell recovery may represent an indication for anti-HCV
therapy.
Comment: There is a prevalent impression that end-stage
liver disease ascribed to HCV is relatively common in co-infected
patients. In this study the mortality rate ascribed to liver failure
was only 0.5%. Others have reported similar low rates [BMJ
1990;301:1362]. There are multiple studies of HCV/HIV coinfection,
and most show no difference in the rate of HIV-related complications
[CID 1993;17:117; Am J Med 1999;107:79S; AIDS 1998;12:381].
Many studies show this coinfection has major consequences in terms
of the rate of progressive liver disease due to HCV [JID
1999;179:1254]. The Swiss Cohort Study appears to be the first to
demonstrate an increase in the rate of opportunistic infections
ascribed to HIV and a blunted CD4 cell response to HAART among those
with HCV coinfection compared to those with HIV alone. Nevertheless,
the difference is not great and appears to be statistically significant
primarily because of the large sample size of over 1,000 patients.
In an editorial published one week later, C. Graham and M. J. Koziel
from the BI Deaconess Medical Center [Lancet 2000;356:1865]
point out that co-infected patients may benefit from therapy directed
against HCV to reduce the frequency of HCV-related liver disease
and also to increase effectiveness of HAART.
posted
1/4/2001

|

|