
|
Association
of Initial CD4 Cell Count and Viral Load With Response to Highly
Active Antiretroviral Therapy [Chaisson RE, et al. JAMA
2000;284:3128]: This
is a retrospective analysis of the Moore Clinic Database to determine
the relationship of baseline CD4 count and viral load with likelihood
of response with a viral load <400 c/mL on at least one occasion
within six months and "durable response," defined as no
level >1,000 c/mL. The results showed a direct correlation between
the CD4 cell count and the probability of initial response and durable
response, and an inverse relationship between the viral load and
initial response and durable response. Details are provided for
the CD4 cell count at baseline in the following table:
| Response
to HAART Based on Baseline CD4 Count |
|
CD4
strata
|
No. |
Initial response* |
Durable response**
|
| >350/mm3 |
158 |
122 (77%)
|
61 (39%)
|
| 200 - 350/mm3 |
118 |
73 (62%) |
34 (29%)
|
| <200/mm3
|
271 |
153 (56%)
|
50 (19%)
|
| *
VL decrease to <400 c/mL |
| **
VL <1,000 c/mL throughout observation period. |
Comment: There is a current debate regarding the CD4 threshold
to initiate antiretroviral therapy. Prior DHHS guidelines recommended
treatment when the CD4 cell count was <500/mm3
and the viral load >10,000 - 20,000/mL [Ann Intern Med 1998;128:1079].
There has subsequently been a re-evaluation of the CD4 cell count
threshold with the observation that no study has demonstrated clinical
benefit with therapy initiated when the CD4 cell count was >350/mm3,
and there is even some debate about benefit when the CD4 cell count
is >200/mm3.
An additional issue concerns the difficulty encountered with adherence
and the long-term toxicity of antiretroviral agents. The result is
a re-thinking of the indications to initiate therapy [JAMA
2000;283:381]. The study above is retrospective, but suggests that
benefit in the form of viral load response is more likely with a CD4
cell count >350/mm3
when HAART is started. Unfortunately, there are no prior or on-going
prospective studies that are designed to examine this issue specifically.
posted
1/18/2001

|

|